Gavin Newsom’s Comments on Transgender Athletes Spark Debate

Mar 16

California Governor Calls Transgender Participation in Women’s Sports “Deeply Unfair”

This blog post is based on the article “California Governor Gavin Newsom Says Transgender Athletes Playing in Women’s Sports Is ‘Deeply Unfair’” published by Vanity Fair on March 10, 2025.

Understanding the Debate and Why It Matters

California Governor Gavin Newsom recently made comments about transgender athletes competing in women’s sports. He said it is “deeply unfair” for transgender women (people who were born male but now identify as female) to compete against women who were born female.

This issue has become a major debate in the U.S. Some people say everyone should have the right to play in the category that matches their gender identity. Others say sports should be divided based on biological sex to keep the competition fair for women.

For immigrants in San Diego and across the U.S., this issue is important because it affects politics, laws, and public opinion. It is also part of a bigger discussion about fairness, rights, and equality in American society.

Newsom’s Conversation With Charlie Kirk

A Surprising Discussion on His Own Podcast

In the first episode of his new podcast, “This Is Gavin Newsom,” Governor Newsom spoke with Charlie Kirk, a well-known conservative political activist.

They discussed many political topics, including how Democrats lost the 2024 election and how they can win back support from voters.

Kirk, who supports former President Donald Trump, asked Newsom if he agreed that transgender women competing in female sports is unfair. Newsom did not correct Kirk when he misgendered a transgender athlete and instead agreed that the issue is about fairness, saying:

“Well, I think it's an issue of fairness. I completely agree with you on that. It’s deeply unfair.”

While Newsom did not say he supports a ban, he made it clear that he believes this issue is a real problem.

How People Reacted to Newsom’s Comments

LGBTQ+ Groups Express Disappointment

Many LGBTQ+ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer) activists criticized Newsom for his statement.

Tony Hoang, director of Equality California, an LGBTQ+ advocacy group, said:

“Instead of standing strong, the governor has added to the heartbreak and fear caused by the relentless attacks from the Trump Administration.”

Chris Ward, a California lawmaker, also expressed disappointment, saying:

“We woke up incredibly sickened and disappointed because somebody who’s been a consistent ally of our community made these remarks.”

These critics believe Newsom is agreeing with conservative politicians who want to limit transgender rights.

Why This Debate Matters for Immigrants

For many immigrants, the transgender sports debate may seem confusing or not directly related to their daily lives. However, it is part of a larger political struggle in the U.S. that affects:

✔ How laws are made and enforced – The same government that makes decisions about transgender rights also creates immigration policies. If lawmakers focus on cultural debates, they may ignore bigger issues like immigration reform.

✔ Public opinion and discrimination – In America, political debates often influence how different groups are treated. If the government takes away rights from one group, it may lead to restrictions on others, including immigrants.

✔ Voting and elections – Issues like transgender rights, abortion, and immigration can decide elections. If Democrats want to win back voters, they may change their policies, which could impact future immigration laws.

Amba Law’s Position: Fairness in Sports Matters

At Amba Law, we believe that Governor Newsom’s comments about fairness in women’s sports were important. Many people, including immigrants who have daughters competing in school sports, care about keeping competition fair.

Women’s sports were created because biological differences between men and women affect athletic ability. Allowing biological males (transgender women) to compete in female categories has led to:

Female athletes losing scholarships and competition spots
Fewer records and titles won by women
Young female athletes feeling discouraged from competing

Ignoring these issues hurts women’s sports and creates unfair advantages.

How This Issue Affected the 2024 Election

The Democratic Party lost the 2024 election in part because they did not address public concerns about fairness in women’s sports.

Donald Trump used this issue to appeal to moderate and independent voters, positioning himself as someone who protects fairness in sports and women’s rights.
Democratic leaders struggled to respond, and many Americans felt disconnected from the party.
Voters in key states, including some who previously supported Democrats, felt that their concerns were ignored.

Newsom’s comments signal that some Democrats may be reconsidering their stance to reconnect with voters.

Newsom’s Leadership Stands Out

Unlike many other politicians, Newsom is willing to talk about fairness in women’s sports. Instead of following the traditional Democratic position, he is:

✔ Recognizing that fairness in sports is a real issue
✔ Acknowledging that many Americans—both liberals and conservatives—are concerned
✔ Trying to rebuild trust with moderate and independent voters

This could make Newsom a stronger presidential candidate in 2028.

Final Thoughts: What Immigrants Should Learn from This Debate

For immigrants in San Diego and across the U.S., this debate is about more than just sports. It is part of a larger political struggle that affects:

✔ How laws are made and who controls the government
✔ What issues political leaders prioritize
✔ How different communities—including immigrants—are treated

At Amba Law, we support fairness, common sense, and real discussions about important issues. We believe Governor Newsom’s willingness to speak honestly is a step in the right direction.

For immigrants, the key takeaway is:

✔ Stay informed – Even if a debate does not seem related to immigration, it can still affect laws, elections, and policies.
✔ Know your rights – Laws and policies can change quickly, and it is important to stay aware of legal protections for all communities.
✔ Pay attention to elections – Political leaders shape policies on many issues, including immigration, healthcare, education, and employment.

The debate over transgender athletes in women’s sports is not just about sports—it reflects the broader political landscape. As the U.S. moves toward the 2028 election, it will be important to watch how leaders like Newsom navigate these issues.

At Amba Law, we remain committed to helping immigrants understand the changing political and legal landscape so they can make informed decisions about their futures in the U.S.

Yasin Amba

Amba Law Legal Immigration Services Consult

$100.00

Amba Law Immigration Legal Services Consultation

Navigating the complexities of U.S. immigration law can be challenging, whether you're a green card holder, a citizen, an asylum applicant, or a refugee. At Amba Law, we offer personalized consultations to help you understand your legal options and rights.

Our Services Include:

Green Card Holders: Guidance on maintaining permanent resident status, understanding re-entry permits, and pathways to U.S. citizenship.
U.S. Citizens: Assistance with family reunification petitions, citizenship documentation, and other immigration-related matters.
Asylum Applicants and Refugees: Support in navigating the asylum process, adjusting status, and accessing available benefits.

Why Choose Amba Law?

Personal Experience: Our team comprises immigrants who have personally navigated the complexities of the U.S. immigration system. This firsthand experience enables us to offer empathetic and informed guidance tailored to your unique journey.
Nationwide Accessibility: Through virtual consultations, we provide expert legal advice to clients across all 50 states, ensuring you have access to our services regardless of your location.
Expertise: Our attorneys stay current with evolving immigration laws to deliver accurate and effective counsel.
Personalized Approach: We take the time to understand your specific circumstances, tailoring our advice to meet your individual needs.
Confidentiality: Your privacy is paramount. All consultations are conducted with the utmost discretion and professionalism.

📌 Standard: $100

📌For Refugees: $50 (Please contact Amba Law Immigration Solutions before proceeding to checkout so we can verify your refugee status or that of your parents. Upon confirmation of eligibility, we will provide you with a unique code to receive a 50% discount.)

Don't navigate your immigration journey alone. Schedule a consultation with Amba Law today to explore your options and secure your future in the United States.

Amba Law's Priority Choice Application Assistance Service

$400.00

Navigating the San Diego Unified School District's (SDUSD) Priority Choice Application process can be complex and time-sensitive. To support families in securing the best educational opportunities for their children, Amba Law offers specialized services to guide parents through each step of the application, ensuring accuracy and timely submission.

Service Offerings:

Initial Consultation:
Purpose: Meet with the family to assess the student's educational needs and determine suitable school options within the SDUSD Choice program.
Details: This session includes a comprehensive overview of the Choice application process, important deadlines, and an evaluation of the student's academic interests and goals. Additionally, we will assist families in researching and identifying the top three school options that best align with the student's needs, considering factors such as location, academic programs, and extracurricular activities.

Consult Fees

Standard: $100
Refugees: $50

2.Application Assistance:

For Refugee Families ($150):
- Services Included:
  - Collaborative completion of the Choice application with parents and students.
  - Guidance on selecting appropriate schools and programs that align with the student's needs.
  - Monitoring the application status post-submission to address any additional requirements or follow-ups.
Standard Fee ($300):
- Services Included:
  - All services provided in the refugee package.
  - Additional support tailored to the specific needs of non-refugee applicants.

Total Fees

1. 📌Standard: $400

2. 📌For Refugees: $200 (Please contact Amba Law Immigration Solutions before proceeding to checkout so we can verify your refugee status or that of your parents. Upon confirmation of eligibility, we will provide you with a unique code to receive a 50% discount.)

Embarking on the journey to secure a spot in your desired school is significant. Amba Law is here to provide expert guidance and support to make the application process as smooth and successful as possible.

Amba Law's Preuss School UCSD Application Assistance Service

Securing admission to The Preuss School UCSD can be a transformative opportunity for students, especially those from refugee backgrounds. Recognizing the complexities of the application process, Amba Law offers specialized services to guide families through each step, ensuring applications are accurately completed and submitted on time.

2012: Newsweek Again Names The Preuss School UCSD the Nation’s Top Transformative High School

https://today.ucsd.edu/story/newsweek_again_names_the_preuss_school_ucsd_the_nations_top_transformative

Initial Consultation:

Purpose: Meet with the student and family to assess the student's eligibility and determine if The Preuss School UCSD aligns with the student's academic goals.
Details: This session includes a comprehensive overview of the school's admission requirements and an evaluation of the student's academic records.
Consult Fees
- Standard: $100
- Refugees: $50

For Refugee Families ($150):
- Services Included:
  - Collaborative completion of the application with parents and students.
  - Guidance on gathering and organizing necessary documentation.
  - Monitoring the application status post-submission to address any additional requirements or follow-ups.
Standard Fee ($300):
- Services Included:
  1. All services provided in the refugee package.
  2. Additional support tailored to the specific needs of non-refugee applicants.

📌 Standard: $400
📌For Refugees: $200 (Please contact Amba Law Immigration Solutions before proceeding to checkout so we can verify your refugee status or that of your parents. Upon confirmation of eligibility, we will provide you with a unique code to receive a 50% discount.) .